He says that the russian generals soon adapted their tactics, so that after. Until his death in 2000, artyom borovik was considered one of the preeminent journalists in russia. If peace was not brought and the war became severed, and they trumps war strategy continued to become implemented in afghanistan, perhaps iran and russia would show more. Jan 29, 2019 president trump claimed the soviet union went to war in 1979 to battle terrorists. Ali ahmadjalali, former afghan army and mujahideen commander and. I learned more about the details of this war in a single chapter from this book than i have in all the other books combined. Grunts, generals, russians and keyboard warriors top our nonfiction list. Washington ap the fight in afghanistan is at a stalemate, and the significant number of afghan troop deaths in the war is not sustainable, the marine officer nominated to command u. Browse the amazon editors picks for the best books of 2019, featuring our favorite. It is the definitive history of the us civil war it gives equal treatment to both sides, and is more than one million words, but is never boring. How a superpower fought and lost modern war studies by the russian general staff, lester w.
The main body of the book is about soviet army and air force tactics, operations, and armaments. The best books on understanding the war in afghanistan five. Elliot is a good writer but not that much of a thinker. The story of the soviet occupation of afghanistan is well known. From iraq and afghanistan to syria and iran, from russia and china to north korea and islamist terrorism, trump and his generals is a brilliant reckoning with an american ship of state navigating a roiling sea of threats without a wellfunctioning rudder. Vycheslav borisov was the deputy chief commander of his nations 100,000 combat troops. Extensive price list for thousands of authentic items representing history of soviet empire from 1917 to 1991 with emphasis on early years and war with nazi germany. Rodric braithwaite, the last british ambassador to the soviet union and the author of afgantsy. Angloafghan wars britishafghani history britannica.
Two russian veterans of the soviet afghan war privately warned general stanley mcchrystal last summer that the key to winning the war would be to pay off the taliban. Russia was fearful of british commercial and military inroads into central asia, and britain was fearful of russia. We feature orders, medals, ids and other attributes of power. First of all, the goal of any war is established by the civilian. As trump doubles down on afghanistan, russians shake their. As a foreign correspondent for the new york times, filkins begins his book as the taliban rises to power in afghanistan, writes of the aftermath following. It covers basically everything phases of war, organisation of soviet forces, their equipment, training, tactics of mujahideen, soviet tactics. The 14 best military nonfiction books of alltime americas. Apr 24, 2017 americas top general in afghanistan has said there was no doubt that russia was providing weapons to the taliban. Afghanistan, and bin laden from the soviet invasion to september 10, 2001 by. As retired afghan air force general atiqullah amarkhel noted in a recent interview, senior russian generals believe that a military intervention. The art of war by sun tzumore than 2,000 years old and still relevant today, the art of war is a mustread book on military theory and strategy. But i started working on afghanistan again in 2009 when i served as an adviser to general mcchrystal and then went back briefly in 2010 to do an assessment for.
Russias war in afghanistan by david isby goodreads. If you want to gain an understanding of americas war with radical islamists, look no further than the forever war by journalist dexter filkins. Dec 24, 2018 goodbye war on terror, hello china and russia. Aug 24, 2017 the us presidents decision to extend the war, reversing his campaign pledges to withdraw from it, stand in sharp contrast to the lessons that mikhail gorbachev and the ussr took from the conflict. Bpduring the former soviet unions war with afghanistan, soviet gen. American generals win lost afghan war veterans today. This is the 7th book on the sovietafghan war ive read, and lester grau kept up his reputation with this book for historical investigative detail. Sort out afghanistan mess or russia will intervene pak army source says collapse in security means west faces losing control by newsdesk. But a newly published cable underscores moscows fear that afghanistan would switch loyalties to the west. Russias goal, he asserted, was to undermine the united states and nato in afghanistan, expressing a far more skeptical view of the. It is definitely not a book without merit, but the places in between is just so much more. Best iraq and afghanistan war books some of the best books out there about the wars in iraq and afghanistan.
More recent works, however, especially by the russian general staff. President trump claimed the soviet union went to war in 1979 to battle terrorists. The soviet afghan war was a conflict wherein insurgent groups known collectively as the mujahideen, as well as smaller maoist groups, fought a guerrilla war against the soviet army and the democratic republic of afghanistan government for over nine years, throughout the 1980s, mostly in the afghan countryside. What is pakistans new game with trumps high flying generals. The translatoreditor established his credentials with his first two books on this subject. Goodbye war on terror, hello china and russia foreign policy. A new account of the soviet unions long, hard battle in afghanistan. Entrapping the us in a mediatory role in the region is a. The army university press the us armys premier multimedia organization focuses on advancing the ideas and insights military professionals need to lead and succeed. T his is the book that every politician, every general, every diplomat contemplating getting into, or out of, afghanistan should be made to.
Nov 30, 2017 russia provided logistical support and supply routes for the u. The great game was a political and diplomatic confrontation that existed for most of the 19th century between the british empire and the russian empire over afghanistan and neighbouring territories in central and south asia. The british empire, in the early 19th century, ruled india through the east india company, and the russian empire, to the north, was suspected of having its own designs on india. Russias war in afghanistan by david isby, ronald volstad. The british wanted to conquer afghanistan to prevent the russians from invading southward through the mountainous regions into british india. The soviet union intervened in support of the afghan communist government in its conflict with anticommunist muslim guerrillas during the afghan war 197892 and remained in afghanistan until midfebruary 1989.
British royal marines take part in the clearance of nade ali district of helmand province. The russians in afghanistan, 197989 main by sir rodric braithwaite isbn. Soviet war in afghanistan simple english wikipedia, the. The army university press is the armys entry point for cutting edge thought and discussion on topics important to the army and national defense. Mar 19, 2011 t his is the book that every politician, every general, every diplomat contemplating getting into, or out of, afghanistan should be made to read. New general takes over in afghanistan amid questions about the u. Following a protracted civil war that began in 1816, the barakzay clan became the ruling dynasty of afghanistan, with its most powerful member, dost mo. Dont abandon afghanistan after 2014 handover, plead generals exclusive. The sovietafghan war was a conflict wherein insurgent groups known collectively as the mujahideen, as well as smaller maoist groups, fought a guerrilla war against the soviet army and the democratic republic of afghanistan government for over nine years, throughout the 1980s, mostly in the afghan countryside. Americas top general in afghanistan has said there was no doubt that russia was providing weapons to the taliban. This is a colection of soviet general staff papers on afghanistan war.
Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Russia provided logistical support and supply routes for the u. Us general in afghanistan says there is no doubt russia is. The soviet war in afghanistan was a war initially fought between the forces of the afghanistan government and afghan assistance fighters, supporter from abroad. Nevertheless, russia fielded enough cannonfodder, and allied officers led poorly enough, that a grinding stalemate was reached. Dec 01, 2009 a former commander of soviet forces in afghanistan has warned history is being repeated in the warravaged country as the united states and its allies become increasingly mired in an unwinnable war. Mike scaparrotti see russias hand in afghanistan and elsewhere in the region as a way to shore up its borders. British commander voices fears that taliban will exploit power vacuum in afghanistan after west quits published. How the generals are routing the policy wonks at the pentagon. But beneath the surface, there are important differences. Without proper equipment and training, the afghanistan government was unable to resist the opposition,called the mujahedeen, eventually seeking the aid of the soviet union. The written recorded history of the land presently constituting afghanistan can be traced back to around 500 bce when the area was under the achaemenid. A former commander of soviet forces in afghanistan has warned history is being repeated in the warravaged country as the united states and its allies become increasingly mired in an unwinnable war. In the strongest statement yet over russias apparent reengagement in the.
Asked about russias activity in afghanistan, where it fought a bloody war in the 1980s and withdrew in defeat, mattis alluded to the. Makhmut akhmetovich gareyev was a russian general of the army and an author of several. For anyone interested in the war in afghanistan, this should be required reading. The entry of the soviet union into the country caused an. Soviet invasion of afghanistan, military action carried out in late december 1979 by soviet troops. David c isby is an experienced observer of afghanistan and the afghan wars. But a newly published cable underscores moscows fear. Of course, russia had numbersand if russia in the 1850s had the railroads or infrastructure to get those troops and supplies into the field, it might have been a different story. As trump doubles down on afghanistan, russians shake their heads. Kenneth mckenzie warned the senate armed services committee against an abrupt. The us presidents decision to extend the war, reversing his campaign pledges to withdraw from it, stand in sharp contrast to the lessons that mikhail gorbachev and the ussr took from the conflict. Russian general accepts christ in damascus road experience.
Why russia wants the us to stay in afghanistan the diplomat. War in afghanistan 2001present part of the larger afghanistan conflict, and the global war on terrorism. Austin miller, seen here in 2014, is the united states newest commander in. That convergence has allowed the two countries to work together.
Sep 01, 2018 new general takes over in afghanistan amid questions about the u. Apr 25, 2017 asked about russias activity in afghanistan, where it fought a bloody war in the 1980s and withdrew in defeat, mattis alluded to the increasing u. The soviet war in afghanistan reprint by gregory feifer isbn. David loyn breaks this book down into four parts, each concentrating on an era of afghanistan and its neighbors persia and the everlooming threat of the russian empire, which had fought for control over that area in the last 200 years. If you compare the books written by russian and american generals, you would realize that the american generals have not illustrated the real condition of the afghan war.
Offering a large selection of soviet and russian items from the revolution through wwii and beyond. In 1989, he was the chief military adviser in afghanistan after the withdrawal of a limited contingent of soviet troops from there. Gareev served as an editorinchief and authored a few books himself. This epic threevolume masterpiece is to war what gibbons decline and fall of the roman empire was to history. Yuri tukharinov, then commander of the soviet forces in afghanistan, later. His views of afghanistan are very romantic and blackandwhite, and the book is a lot about him. With the hidden war he provided the world its first glimpse inside the soviet military machine, capturing the soldiers terror, helplessness, and despair at waging war in a foreign land against an unseen enemy for unclear purposes. New general takes over in afghanistan amid questions about. His travels are exciting, but compared to the places in between, they fall flat. With great britain and russia maneuvering for influence in afghanistan, dost mo. Feifer gives credence to the assertion of one general staff officer that no. Lucid and gripping, it brings urgently needed clarity to issues that affect the fate of us.
Aug 23, 2017 as retired afghan air force general atiqullah amarkhel noted in a recent interview, senior russian generals believe that a military intervention in afghanistan would overextend moscows. The russians in afghanistan, 197989, said on monday that it had long been known that the kremlin worried that mr. Sometimes the hardest part of going to war is coming home by. The origins and conduct of the war and the operational organisation of soviet forces are discussed. Dec 22, 2009 on the 30th anniversary of russia s invasion of afghanistan, russian vets talk about losing more than 14,000 lives in their afghanistan war that ended in retreat. How five great commanders saved wars that were lost by victor davis hanson. Kenneth mckenzie warned the senate armed services committee against an abrupt withdrawal of american forces or change in strategy despite. Some of the best books out there about the wars in iraq and afghanistan score a books total score is based on multiple factors, including the number of people who have voted for it and how highly those voters ranked the book.
No state has been as supportive of islamist terrorism as the united states and its governments, from president jimmy carter onwards. Dec 04, 2018 washington ap the fight in afghanistan is at a stalemate, and the significant number of afghan troop deaths in the war is not sustainable, the marine officer nominated to command u. On the 30th anniversary of russias invasion of afghanistan, russian vets talk about losing more than 14,000 lives in their afghanistan war that ended in retreat. The mujahideen were backed primarily by the united states, saudi arabia, pakistan. The most interesting aspect, in my opinion, is the authors prediction the book was written in 1986 that the war would last some 20 years and that nobody ever won a war of atrittion against russia soviet union at the time but the author keep calling it russia. May 06, 2011 dont abandon afghanistan after 2014 handover, plead generals exclusive. This book tells of five different generals, each who came in and saved a war that was otherwise likely to be lost. For the last decade and a half, russia and the united states have had largely similar aims in afghanistan. Soviet combat tactics in afghanistan had help deciphering the russian general staff papers from gress, a soviet migr who served in the soviet army. General seeks a few thousand more troops in afghanistan. In the strongest statement yet over russia s apparent reengagement in the. Feb 09, 2017 russias goal, he asserted, was to undermine the united states and nato in afghanistan, expressing a far more skeptical view of the kremlins intentions than president trump. While the book was later made into a movie, its wellworth reading if only for the stories of rick rescorla, the platoon leader featured on the cover of the book whose nickname was hard core. Those generals are themistocles, belisarius, sherman, ridgway in korea, and petraeus in iraq.
1391 238 643 563 16 1474 1353 988 152 1117 874 1377 980 133 1054 180 64 380 66 1339 1034 1270 190 132 894 167 74 619 590 239 1017 165 974 286 416 594 1248 9 165